Jacob raab

Depends what I'm in the mood for but more times than not I want NY style

ShrimplyPibblez 

Albert Long

I'm not a fan of the red sauce and Chicago style has a lot of it.

Pawpaw

MaryBeth Zmuda

I like both, I just have been a bit influenced from a pizza place near us

Derrick McQuinn

Chicago and it ain’t even close. Give me that beautiful, thick, buttery crust any day of the week.

Daniel

New York is better, because it’s crunchy and you can fold it in half and eat it better, no fork and knife needed...

Boss Jose

DoctorQuarterZ

Jason Finley

I've lived in NY and Chicago. They both have excellent pies, so it's the style of thin vs thick. I like thin NY style by a wide margin but Chicago pizza is great. Pizza for all!

Bob Rauch

VERIFIED

Gotta be the thin new york style because not a big fin of too much sauce

Austin schwerdt

Both are good but always preferred the “thin crust” New York style.

What’s better, and why ?