Who is the best catcher in St Louis Cardinals history?

42 votes

• Yadier Molina 2004-Present - 24 votes
• Ted Simmons 1968-1980 - 8 votes
• Tim McCarver 1959-1974 - 6 votes
• Tom Pagnozzi 1987-1998 - 3 votes
• Other, please name! - 1 votes
• Mike Matheny 2000-2004 - 0 votes

Poll by Pawpaw