If you’re the 49ers would you rather have Tom Brady or Jimmy Garappolo next season?

Alex Padilla

ADMIN

VERIFIED

SUPERADMIN

Brady for sure. JG looked like he wanted to be TB. He is not as accurate at TB.. Stats mean nothing, Results are everything.

Rick

He didn’t win and seemed to be a big part of them losing the super bowl...doesn’t have the credentials Brady does but he did do his part to get them to the Big show! Gotta go with the hot hand and younger upside and vote Jimmy G.  Who knows if Brady has anything left and history has proven once a QB is done it happens overnight and with very little to no warning.

Joe Rigby

Tom Brady is a proven winner not just Tom Brady light.

andybnerdy

Juliana Guidi

More upside with the young gun. Plus, no cheating allegations.

Younger, longterm option, got them to the Super Bowl.

Zach McCaleb

Mary Beth Polk

Let me ask it this way, if you are the 49ers and you think you can win it all in 2020/21 and your choice was Jimmy G or Brady, who do you believe gives you a better chance to win it all?This is East, Brady all day long. Please don’t tell me about Brady’s age or diminishing skills, it’s his leadership that ultimately is why players would prefer Brady and his winning formula, vs Jimmy G and his inability to make the clutch throw in crunch time!

Scott Kaplan

With the talent they have currently, Brady. And with Garappolos age I don't expect there to be much more growth.